Is Coffee Creamer Bad for You? Here’s a Dietitian’s Take - GoodRx (2024)

Coffee is one of the most popular and beloved drinks in the U.S. And on its own, coffee is a healthy beverage that comes with several health benefits. But the coffee creamers that many people add to their coffee don’t offer those same health advantages.

Most coffee creamers are highly processed and contain artificial ingredients, saturated fat, and high amounts of added sugar. For these reasons, coffee creamer is something you’re generally better off leaving out of your daily cup of joe.

Coffee creamer ingredients

Despite the name, most coffee creamers don’t actually contain any cream at all. Ingredients vary somewhat by brand, but common coffee creamer ingredients are:

• Sugar

• Hydrogenated oils, which are mostly saturated fats

• Artificial and/or natural flavors

• Thickeners like guar gum, cellulose gum, and carrageenan

• Chemical additives like dipotassium phosphate, an emulsifier that allows creamers to be shelf-stable, plus other emulsifiers like mono- and diglycerides

• Artificial sweeteners

• Corn syrup solids, a glucose-based sweetener made from liquid corn syrup

Coffee creamer nutrition facts

Nutrition specifics vary depending on the brand and product.

To provide an example, below are the nutrition panels for two best-selling varieties of coffee creamer. The first one (left) is traditional, and the second one (right) is plant-based.

Neither of them provide any significant nutritional value.

The verdict: Is coffee creamer bad for you?

Most coffee creamers — even if advertised as healthy — are not good for your health. Looking at sugar content alone, coffee creamer often contains 1 tsp of sugar per 1 tbsp of serving size. This can quickly add up, particularly if you consume more than the one serving each day. For reference, the American Heart Association (AHA) recommends no more than:

• 6 tsp of added sugar for men (equal to 6 tbsp of creamer)

• 9 tsp of added sugar for women (equal to 9 tbsp of creamer)

Most coffee creamers are high in food additives, artificial flavors, and chemicals. And they are low in necessary nutrients. This is true whether the creamer is sugar-free or fat-free, or if it comes in powder or liquid form.

Recent research has found numerous food additives to be harmful to humans due to their potential to cause a variety of health issues. For example, carrageenan is present in many coffee creamers. This chemical has been found to cause inflammation in the intestines and may play a role in the development of gastrointestinal disorders like ulcerative colitis and Crohn's disease.

Ultimately, there isn’t enough research to determine whether the common ingredients used in coffee creamers are actually safe for you. But there are safer coffee creamer alternatives.

How to choose coffee creamer alternatives

If you don’t want to drink your coffee black, you have other options with less harmful ingredients.

In general, the simpler the product, the better it is for you. The best way to identify a simple product is by looking at its ingredients list. Fewer ingredients on the list means that less has been added to the product. This means the food product is closer to its natural state.

For example, the only ingredients in half-and-half are milk and cream. Since it’s half cream and half whole milk, half-and-half is lower in saturated fat and calories than heavy cream. It also contains no additives, artificial flavors, or sugar. This makes half-and-half an inexpensive, convenient, and healthier alternative to other coffee creamers.

If you’re looking for a dairy-free option, your best bet is to stick to pure, unsweetened plant-based milks. Examples include almond, soy, or oat milk.

If you like flavored coffee, you can try adding in a small amount of pure vanilla extract or a sprinkle of cinnamon.

If you crave sweeter coffee, you can consider adding a small amount of natural sweeteners like stevia or monk fruit. Bottled flavored syrups, on the other hand, are loaded with sugar and artificial ingredients and aren’t better for you than most coffee creamers. This even applies to syrups labeled “sugar-free.” They likely contain artificial sweeteners, which come with their own health risks.

There can still be a time and place for using commercially prepared coffee creamers. When you consume them sparingly, they’re not likely to pose any serious health risk. The problem is that many people drink coffee every day, and in large amounts. That’s why choosing a healthier coffee creamer alternative is your best bet for daily use.